How Emergency Physician Staffing Lowers The Left Without Being Seen Rate
When an emergency department fills up, some patients sign in, wait, and leave before a physician or advanced practice provider sees them. Their share of visits is the left without being seen (LWBS) rate, and it tends to fall when patients reach a provider sooner.
In several published studies, the changes that got patients to a provider sooner were in physician coverage and triage staffing.
TECHealth sees the problem from two sides. It provides physician and APP staffing in hospital emergency departments, and it owns and operates The Emergency Center in San Antonio and Conroe, Texas, which was founded in 2014 with a vision for no-wait ER care.
Table Of Contents
- What Left Without Being Seen (LWBS) Means In An Emergency Department
- What An LWBS Patient Costs An ER
- Why Patients Leave Before A Provider Sees Them
- Staffing Changes That Lower The LWBS Rate
- How TECHealth Runs Its Own ERs For No-Wait Care
- Questions To Ask An ER Staffing Partner About LWBS
- Related Reading From TECHealth
- Resources On Left Without Being Seen
- Learn More About TECHealth ER Staffing
What Left Without Being Seen (LWBS) Means In An Emergency Department
LWBS describes a patient who signs in for emergency care and leaves before a qualifying provider evaluates them. Under the 2020 specifications for the CMS hospital outpatient measure OP-22, that meant leaving before evaluation by a physician, advanced practice nurse or physician assistant, with residents and interns counted as physician evaluation.
Nurse triage on its own doesn’t count as being seen. A patient can go through routine nurse triage and still count as LWBS under OP-22 if they leave before that evaluation, and the denominator is every patient who signed in for emergency evaluation.
The Emergency Department Benchmarking Alliance draws the line a little earlier. Its 2020 definitions count a patient who leaves before the medical screening exam starts as LWBS.
Nationally, CDC estimated that 1.7% of U.S. hospital emergency department visits in 2021 ended with the patient leaving without being seen, and 1.9% in 2022. For a hospital reviewing its ER staffing, that rate is one of the plainest signs of whether patients reach a provider in time.
Is Left Without Being Seen The Same As Leaving Against Medical Advice?
No. A patient who leaves without being seen goes before a qualifying provider evaluates them. Under the Emergency Department Benchmarking Alliance’s 2020 definitions, leaving against medical advice comes later, after a qualified provider has evaluated the patient and treatment has begun, and it’s grouped with elopements as left subsequent to being seen. CDC’s 2022 national survey also reported leaving against medical advice and leaving before treatment was complete as separate dispositions.
Is CMS Still Collecting The LWBS Measure?
For now. In its CY 2026 hospital outpatient final rule, CMS scheduled the standalone OP-22 measure to end starting with the 2028 reporting period, which applies to the 2030 payment determination. Its replacement, the Emergency Care Access & Timeliness measure, includes departures before evaluation by a physician, advanced practice nurse or physician assistant as one component. Reporting is voluntary for CY 2027 and mandatory from CY 2028.
What An LWBS Patient Costs An ER
A patient who leaves without being seen costs the emergency department the visit it didn’t complete, and many of those patients come back later. At the 2022 national rate of 1.9%, an emergency department with 30,000 visits a year would see about 570 of them.
The clearest published cost figures come from a 2021 study of 18 emergency departments in one health system, using visits from 2019.
For visits that ended before the medical screening exam was complete and had missing charges or charges below the average for the site and acuity, the researchers estimated potential net fees of $146 per encounter for professional services and $539 per encounter for technical services. Across the system, that came to about $5.6 million in potential net fees, before any revenue recaptured when patients returned.
In the same study, 14.5% of ED return encounters within 30 days and within the same system resulted in admission. At one Midwestern emergency department in a separate 2021 study, just over half of adults who left unseen had another encounter in the same health system within three weeks.
Of the patients in that Midwestern study whose first related follow-up was an ED visit in the same system, 78.1% returned within 72 hours. So the cost shows up twice: the visit that ended early, and the bed and staff time a returning patient needs.
The cost is mostly to the department, at least in the largest outcome study. In a 2011 study of high-volume emergency departments in Ontario, Canada, patients who left unseen had no higher adjusted odds of death or hospital admission within seven days than patients who were seen and discharged.
Why Patients Leave Before A Provider Sees Them
Patients leave when the wait to see a provider runs long and the department is full. At one academic emergency department in a 2020 study, longer waits to see a provider were linked to higher odds of leaving unseen, and the odds rose as the waiting room filled.
The same study linked more patients boarding, admitted patients waiting in the ED for inpatient beds, to higher odds of leaving unseen. Those were associations at one site, so they show what tends to go with LWBS more than what causes it.
A posted wait time can make the wait look shorter than it is. “Usually, the published wait time is the time it takes to see a medical provider,” explains Eric Wilke, MD, TECHealth chief operations officer and a practicing emergency medicine physician. “That just means the initial contact. Not that you’re having your treatment started in that amount of time.”
Capacity is part of it too. “Every year we have more people visiting the emergency room, but at the same time, when you look at the total number of emergency room beds, those are actually going down,” Dr. Wilke says. TECHealth’s article on why emergency rooms are so slow covers boarding and shared hospital resources in more detail.
Staffing Changes That Lower The LWBS Rate
In published studies, the staffing changes tied to lower LWBS rates put a provider in front of patients earlier and matched coverage to when patients arrive. Most come from single emergency departments, so they show what worked in one setting, not a guaranteed result.
Putting a physician at triage is often called provider in triage. A 2020 review of U.S. emergency department studies linked attending physician coverage at triage to lower risk of leaving unseen, with a pooled risk ratio of 0.62. At one urban academic ED in a 2016 study, LWBS during intake hours fell from 5.5% to 0.5% after a split-flow redesign that put an attending physician at intake, a change that coincided with a move into new space.
Matching coverage to arrivals has helped too. A 2006 study at one urban ED found a 22.9% relative drop in LWBS after it reworked provider coverage around arrival patterns and added hours.
At one ED in a 2026 study, LWBS fell from 6.5% to 4.7% after the department increased and staggered attending coverage and gave the triage physician clinical responsibility through disposition. Because the staffing and triage changes came together, the study can’t say which one did more.
Advanced practice providers can add coverage at busy hours. In a 2021 report from one Ontario emergency department, the average daily LWBS rate was 3.4% with physician assistant coverage and 5.2% in the comparison group.
In Texas, a physician delegates prescribing to a PA or APRN through a written prescriptive authority agreement, and the delegating physician stays responsible for the medical acts delegated. TECHealth’s emergency room staffing services in Texas cover emergency medicine physicians and advanced practice providers, both nurse practitioners and physician assistants.
Coverage only helps when the schedule stays filled, and Dr. Wilke says TECHealth hires on values instead of filling shifts at any cost. “A lot of people are desperate for a warm body,” he says.
Does A Texas Freestanding ER Have To Keep A Physician On Site?
Yes. Texas rules require one or more physicians to be on site at all times a freestanding emergency center is open, and licensure requires 24-hour, 7-day operation. Texas rules also require a registered nurse with current ACLS and PALS certification on duty whenever patients are in the facility. So in a Texas freestanding ER, a physician is already in the building whenever a patient walks in.
How TECHealth Runs Its Own ERs For No-Wait Care
The Emergency Center was founded with a vision for no-wait ER care, and its freestanding ERs run as small teams. A physician leads, supported by a nurse, a radiology technologist and front desk staff, with established transfer processes for admission or care beyond a freestanding setting.
“Usually by the time a patient arrives and completes check-in at our registration desk, we’re ready to put them in a room to be cared for,” Dr. Wilke explains. Hospital emergency departments often face a longer queue for tests. “If you send a lab from the emergency room to the hospital’s central lab, it’s put in line with everyone else who’s in the hospital, so you have to wait for the results to come back,” he says.
Dr. Wilke brings that experience to hospital emergency departments as well. After returning to Texas, he created an ED staffing group, Traditions Emergency Medicine, that staffed the College Station Medical Center, and in his role he has coordinated ED flow systems along with graded interviews and hiring.
TECHealth’s ER staffing is run by experienced emergency room physicians and aims to increase the efficiency of patient flow, align the needs of physicians and hospital leadership, and apply constant quality control on each emergency physician. Both freestanding ERs are listed with The Emergency Center locations, and Dr. Wilke and the other physicians who lead the company are introduced with TECHealth leadership.
Questions To Ask An ER Staffing Partner About LWBS
When a hospital compares staffing partners, these questions show how each one would handle patients who leave without being seen:
- Reporting: Will you report the LWBS rate and door to provider time each month, and against what target?
- Definition: Do you count LWBS at CMS’s qualifying evaluation or at the start of the medical screening exam?
- Front End: Who sees patients at triage during peak hours, and does that physician keep the patient through disposition?
- Coverage: How are physician and APP hours set against arrival patterns, and who covers when volume jumps?
- APPs In Texas: How are prescriptive authority agreements and physician supervision handled for the PAs and nurse practitioners you place?
- Turnover: How do you keep the schedule filled, and how long do your physicians stay?
- Measures Ahead: How will you support the Emergency Care Access & Timeliness measure as CMS phases out OP-22?
Freestanding ER owners can also look at TECHealth’s ER partnerships.
Related Reading From TECHealth
Resources On Left Without Being Seen
- CMS CY 2026 Hospital Outpatient Final Rule: the rule that schedules the end of OP-22 and adopts the Emergency Care Access & Timeliness measure.
- CDC National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey, 2022 Emergency Department Summary Tables: the national estimate of visits that ended without the patient being seen (Table 23).
- Health System Study Of LWBS Revenue And Returns, 2021: the 18-ED study of potential fees and return visits after patients left before the screening exam was complete.
- Predictors Of Leaving Without Being Seen At One Academic ED, 2020: the study linking provider wait, waiting room count and boarding to the odds of leaving.
- Attending Physician At Triage, 2020 Review: the pooled analysis of U.S. studies on physician coverage at triage and LWBS.
Learn More About TECHealth ER Staffing
To learn more about how TECHealth staffs emergency departments, visit tec.health/staffing/, call 877-336-6898 or send TECHealth a message. You can also find TECHealth on Google Maps.